The most costly decision in India? Having the wrong person at the helm of your Indian subsidiary.
A Smart Approach to Executive Search in India
When an Indian subsidiary runs into trouble or is simply “drifting along,” most of our clients first look for an explanation in the challenging Indian market, the wrong product, or the complex regulatory environment. However, in over 100 crisis and turnaround projects that we at Dr. Wamser + Batra have managed over two decades, the same pattern has emerged time and again: In nearly 95 percent of cases, the root cause lies in poorly staffed top leadership positions—true to the saying, “The head sets the direction for the body.”
That’s precisely why executive search should be approached strategically. Now you might be thinking, “We already have recruiting expertise in an international context, so it can’t be that different in India.” But honestly? That experience will only help you to a limited extent in India—recruiting at the C-level really does follow different rules here.
If you hire the wrong managing director, you’re setting yourself up for problems that won’t become apparent for a long time.
Has your Indian subsidiary been reporting for years that everything is running smoothly, yet is only breaking even? Pay close attention: This result is often an indication of “internal consumption” (internal cash outflows without transparent consideration), “bypasses” (circumvention of internal control processes), or other compliance- and performance-related issues that have built up under a Managing Director (MD) who either sets the wrong priorities or actively conceals them. Similarly, significant discrepancies in account reconciliations with banks, customers, or suppliers; high employee turnover; sluggish or incorrect monthly reporting; and sluggish communication with headquarters are always warning signs of troubling developments. And almost always a clear consequence of leadership failure.
Filling a key position—such as executive management, finance, or plant management—with the wrong person costs far more than the recruitment expenses: lost revenue, top performers leaving the company, unstable customer relationships, untapped growth potential, legal issues with government agencies…
The losses: often as high as seven figures per year.
In this respect, India is certainly no different from other international markets.
Why Traditional Recruiting Doesn’t Work for Top Positions in India
However, the Indian executive recruitment market has unique characteristics that are impressive in both nature and scope—even when compared to experience in other international markets—and that European companies regularly underestimate:
- No-shows who agree to interviews without any intention of changing jobs. Players who use a concrete counteroffer to open salary negotiations with their current employer. Embellished resumes that seem absolutely convincing at first glance. Questionable college degrees and awards whose authenticity is extremely difficult to verify. Implausible salary figures from previous jobs that cannot be verified. In India, unfortunately, this is not an isolated case in the top tier, but rather an everyday occurrence.
- In addition, most (Indian) recruiters work with databases or pre-compiled lists of candidates. They present the candidate who is available the fastest rather than the best fit. And since their commission ranges from 25–40% of the future annual salary, they tend to favor the more expensive candidates—an incentive that is rarely in the best interest of the hiring company.
- What’s more, networks have a different scope in India than they do in Europe. For example, a cousin might be enthusiastically recommended for a position that he or she is actually not qualified to fill.
The consequences of hiring the wrong person usually don’t become apparent until about 12 to 18 months later. By then , damage has already been done that isn’t so easy to fix.
And there’s another phenomenon at play here: In India, people regularly part ways with executives in a way that preserves their dignity, so that “repeat offenders” can only be identified through exceptional networks. In the course of our many years of work on the ground, we have occasionally encountered the very same executive at multiple client companies—each time as the source of a problem that these clients had initially classified quite differently when they first approached us.
Executive Search for India: Always Conducted from the European Headquarters
That is why the recruitment process for leadership positions must be led by the European headquarters; the responsibility for filling top-level roles in India must not rest solely with the local HR function on the ground. This is the only way to ensure that the leadership position is fully aligned with your goals as the headquarters, both in terms of professional expertise and cultural fit.
This means you need a partner who is familiar with both worlds—European corporate culture and the Indian executive recruitment market. Not a headhunter who simply presents a candidate and then steps back, but someone who stays with you every step of the way.
How We Search—and Why It Makes a Difference
WB is not a traditional headhunting firm. The fact that we now offer executive search services for India is a direct result of our many years of experience: In countless crisis and turnaround engagements, it has become clear that the root cause of many problems lay in the selection of the top executive. In other words: If executive search had been handled differently, the wrong person would never have been appointed to that role in the first place.
Here at Dr. Wamser + Batra, we deliberately always start our search from scratch. We don’t use databases or pre-made lists. We look for candidates who are a perfect fit for this specific position, this specific industry, and this specific state.
Phase 1 – Preparation: Clarity regarding the role, with measurable goals for 12, 24, and 36 months. Market and salary analysis. Honest preliminary risk assessment of the on-site situation. Strategic kick-off meeting with the HQ decision-making group.
Phase 2 – Search & Screening: Long list, short list, and final list with transparent evaluations. Dual interviews from Indian and European perspectives. Integrity check, resume audit, structured reference checks. Assessment of the candidate’s motivation to change jobs early in the process, rather than waiting until a contract offer is made.
Phase 3 – On-the-Job Support: Feedback sessions during the first six months. Quarterly performance reviews. Mediation in the event of conflicts with headquarters.
“Every key position that is properly filled and actively supported prevents financial losses that far exceed the fee for a professional search.”
Mike D. Batra
Management

Are you looking for a managing director for your Indian subsidiary, seeking to fill another senior position in India, or would you like to have an existing hire reviewed critically? Talk to us.
→ Read our second blog post: What to Do Differently Next Time—Six Lessons from the Indian Executive Recruitment Market
Anyone who has ever held a top position in India will recognize these common mistakes. Those who are about to go through the executive search process can avoid them.